Agent skill

Frappe Agent Validator

by Impertio-Studio in Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

A skill your agent uses when reviewing or validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls.

MITAuto-check passedDevelopment

Install Frappe Agent Validator

skills CLI
$ npx skills add Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package --skill frappe-agent-validator -a claude-code

Project install by default; add -g for ~/.claude/skills/.

GitHub CLI
$ gh skill install Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package frappe-agent-validator --agent claude-code

Project scope by default; add --scope user for a personal install. Needs GitHub CLI 2.90.0 or later (public preview).

Manual copy
$ git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package.git skills-src && mkdir -p .claude/skills && cp -r skills-src/skills/source/agents/frappe-agent-validator .claude/skills/frappe-agent-validator && rm -rf skills-src

Use ~/.claude/skills/ instead of .claude/skills for a personal install. The folder must contain SKILL.md.

Claude Code skills documentation · loads skills from .claude/skills/

Facts

Skill name
frappe-agent-validator
GitHub stars
187
Token cost
~2.8k tokens
SKILL.md length
800 words
Files
4 (incl. references)
Skills in repo
61
Repo updated
First seen
Licence
MIT

At a glance

A skill your agent uses when reviewing or validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls.

  • Works in 5 steps: Any import statements? --> FATAL → Any self. references? --> FATAL (use doc.) → Any try/except? --> WARNING (usually… → …
  • Validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls
  • SKILL.md covers When to Use This Agent, Validation Workflow, Critical Checks by Code Type and v16 Specific Validations, plus 5 more sections
  • Instructions only: no scripts, shell commands, URLs or credentials in SKILL.md

What it does

Frappe Agent Validator is an agent skill from Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package. Use when reviewing or validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls. Checks generated code before deployment, validates against all 61 frappe- skills, catches v16 patterns (extenddoctypeclass, type annotations), validates ops patterns (bench commands, deployment), and generates correction reports. Keywords: review code, check script, validate deployment, find bugs, code quality, check my code, is this correct, code review, before deploying, best practices check.

Its SKILL.md is about 2.8k tokens, which your agent loads only when the skill is triggered. The skill folder holds 4 other files, including reference files (for example `references/checklists.md`, `references/examples.md` and `references/workflow.md`). Compatibility notes: Claude Code, Claude.ai Projects, Claude API. Frappe v14-v16.

It sits in Development, covering Code review, Debugging and Deployment. The repository describes itself as: 60 deterministic Claude AI skills for Frappe Framework & ERPNext v14-v16 development and operations. The licence is MIT.

When your agent uses it

  • Validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls
  • Tasks that involve Code review
  • Tasks that involve Debugging

Example prompts

  • “/frappe-agent-validator”

Requirements

  • Python 3
  • Compatibility (from SKILL.md): Claude Code, Claude.ai Projects, Claude API. Frappe v14-v16.

Workflow steps

5 steps, taken from the first numbered list in SKILL.md.

  1. Any import statements? --> FATAL
  2. Any self. references? --> FATAL (use doc.)
  3. Any try/except? --> WARNING (usually wrong)
  4. Uses frappe.throw() for validation? --> GOOD
  5. Uses doc.field for access? --> GOOD

What it can do on your machine

Read from SKILL.md and the folder at commit 36cfa80. It shows what the files ask for, not the result of running them.

  • Tool permissions

    Pre-approves nothing: there is no allowed-tools line, so your agent's usual permission prompts apply.

    From allowed-tools in the SKILL.md frontmatter.

  • Runs code

    No scripts in the folder and no shell commands in SKILL.md (its code samples are python and markdown).

    From the folder's file list and the shell code blocks in SKILL.md.

  • Network

    No URLs in SKILL.md.

    From URLs in SKILL.md, links to its own repository left out.

  • Credentials

    Names no API keys, tokens, secrets or passwords.

    From names ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _KEY or _PASSWORD in SKILL.md.

  • Compatibility

    Claude Code, Claude.ai Projects, Claude API. Frappe v14-v16.

    From compatibility in the SKILL.md frontmatter.

Context cost

Frappe Agent Validator loads about 2.8k tokens when it runs, and up to ~8.5k if it reads all its reference files. Until then it costs about 130 tokens; SKILL.md has 800 words of instructions outside code blocks.

Always · name and description, kept in context so the agent knows when to use it
~130
When it runs · the whole SKILL.md, loaded when a task matches
~2.8k
With references · SKILL.md plus every file in references/, read only if the agent opens them
~8.5k

Estimates: characters ÷ 4, the usual rule of thumb; real counts depend on the model's tokenizer. Scripts and assets cost tokens only if the agent reads them.

Safety

Auto-check passed

The automated check found no risky patterns in SKILL.md.

Automated static check — not a guarantee. Review scripts before installing. It scans the text of SKILL.md for risky patterns (piping downloads into a shell, reading credential files, hidden Unicode, destructive commands); files beside SKILL.md are not scanned.

SKILL.md

The full file from Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package at commit 36cfa80, republished under its MIT licence (© Impertio-Studio). 800 words, ~2,799 tokens.

Download SKILL.mdSave it as .claude/skills/frappe-agent-validator/SKILL.md (or your agent's skills folder). This skill also uses 3 other files; get the full folder from GitHub.
name
frappe-agent-validator
description
Use when reviewing or validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls. Checks generated code before deployment, validates against all 61 frappe-* skills, catches v16 patterns (extend_doctype_class, type annotations), validates ops patterns (bench commands, deployment), and generates correction reports. Keywords: review code, check script, validate deployment, find bugs, code quality, check my code, is this correct, code review, before deploying, best practices check.
compatibility
Claude Code, Claude.ai Projects, Claude API. Frappe v14-v16.
license
MIT
metadata.author
OpenAEC-Foundation
metadata.version
2.0

Frappe Code Validator Agent

Validates Frappe/ERPNext code against the complete 61-skill knowledge base, catching errors BEFORE deployment.

Purpose: Catch errors before deployment, not after

When to Use This Agent

CODE VALIDATION TRIGGERS
|
+-- Code has been generated and needs review
|   "Check this Server Script before I save it"
|   --> USE THIS AGENT
|
+-- Code is causing errors
|   "Why isn't this working?"
|   --> USE THIS AGENT
|
+-- Pre-deployment validation
|   "Is this production-ready?"
|   --> USE THIS AGENT
|
+-- Code review for best practices
|   "Can this be improved?"
|   --> USE THIS AGENT
|
+-- Ops/deployment validation
|   "Is my bench setup correct?"
|   --> USE THIS AGENT

Validation Workflow

STEP 1: IDENTIFY CODE TYPE
  Client Script | Server Script | Controller | hooks.py |
  Jinja | Whitelisted | Bench/Ops | DocType JSON

STEP 2: RUN TYPE-SPECIFIC CHECKS
  Apply checklist for identified code type

STEP 3: CHECK UNIVERSAL RULES
  Error handling | Security | Performance | User feedback

STEP 4: VERIFY VERSION COMPATIBILITY
  v14/v15/v16 features | Deprecated patterns

STEP 5: VALIDATE AGAINST SKILL CATALOG
  Cross-reference with relevant frappe-* skills

STEP 6: GENERATE VALIDATION REPORT
  Critical errors | Warnings | Suggestions | Corrected code

See references/workflow.md for detailed steps.

Critical Checks by Code Type

Server Script Checks
CheckSeverityPatternFix
Import statementsFATALimport X or from X import YUse frappe.utils.X() directly
Wrong doc variableFATALself.field or document.fieldUse doc.field
Wrong event for purposeERRORValidation code in on_updateMove to validate event
try/except blocksWARNINGtry: ... except:Use frappe.throw() for validation
No null checksWARNINGdoc.field.lower()Add if doc.field: guard
Client Script Checks
CheckSeverityPatternFix
Server-side API callsFATALfrappe.db.get_value()Use frappe.call()
Missing async handlingFATALlet x = frappe.call()Use callback or async/await
No refresh after set_valueERRORfrm.set_value() aloneAdd frm.refresh_field()
Using cur_frmWARNINGcur_frm.doc.fieldUse frm parameter
No form state checkWARNINGMissing __islocal/docstatusAdd state guards
Controller Checks
CheckSeverityPatternFix
self.* in on_updateFATALself.field = X in on_updateUse self.db_set()
Circular saveFATALself.save() in lifecycle hookRemove self.save()
Missing super()ERROROverride without super()Add super().method()
v16 extend_doctype_classERRORMissing super() in mixinALWAYS call super() first
No type annotationsSUGGESTIONMissing type hints (v16)Add type annotations
hooks.py Checks
CheckSeverityPatternFix
Invalid Python syntaxFATALSyntax errorsFix dict/list structure
Wrong event namesFATALTypo in event nameUse correct event names
Invalid function pathsFATALWrong dotted pathVerify path exists
v16-only hooks on v14/v15ERRORextend_doctype_classUse doc_events instead
Missing required_appsWARNINGNo dependency declarationAdd all dependencies
Ops/Bench Checks
CheckSeverityPatternFix
No migrate after hooksFATALhooks.py changed, no migrateRun bench migrate
Wrong bench command syntaxERRORIncorrect CLI argsCheck frappe-ops-bench
Missing backup before upgradeERRORUpgrade without backupALWAYS backup first
Production without supervisorWARNINGNo process managerUse supervisor/systemd
No SSL in productionWARNINGHTTP-only deploymentConfigure SSL/TLS
DocType JSON Checks
CheckSeverityPatternFix
Missing mandatory fieldsERRORNo primary identifierAdd name or autoname
Duplicate fieldnamesFATALSame fieldname twiceUse unique fieldnames
Wrong fieldtype for dataWARNINGText for short valuesUse Data/Small Text
No permissions definedWARNINGEmpty permission listAdd role permissions

v16 Specific Validations

extend_doctype_class Pattern
python
# VALIDATE: Mixin class MUST call super()
class CustomSalesInvoice(SalesInvoice):
    def validate(self):
        super().validate()       # REQUIRED - never skip
        self.custom_validation()

    def on_submit(self):
        super().on_submit()      # REQUIRED - never skip
        self.custom_on_submit()
Type Annotations (v16 best practice)
python
# v16 recommended pattern
def get_customer_balance(customer: str) -> float:
    ...

# Validate: type hints on public API methods
@frappe.whitelist()
def process_order(order_name: str, action: str = "approve") -> dict:
    ...
Data Masking (v16)
python
# Validate: sensitive fields should use data masking
# Check if PII fields have mask_with configured in DocType JSON

Universal Validation Rules

Security Checks (ALL code types)
CheckSeverityDescription
SQL InjectionCRITICALRaw user input in SQL
Permission bypassCRITICALMissing permission checks
XSS vulnerabilityHIGHUnescaped user input in HTML
Sensitive data exposureHIGHLogging passwords/tokens
Hardcoded credentialsCRITICALAPI keys in source code
Performance Checks (ALL code types)
CheckSeverityDescription
Query in loopHIGHfrappe.db.* inside for loop
Unbounded queryMEDIUMSELECT without LIMIT
Unnecessary get_docLOWget_doc when get_value suffices
Missing indexMEDIUMFilter on non-indexed field
No batch commitHIGHCommit per record in bulk ops
Show full SKILL.md (326 more words)Show less
Error Handling Checks (ALL code types)
CheckSeverityDescription
Silent failuresHIGHexcept: pass without logging
Missing user feedbackMEDIUMErrors not shown to user
Generic error messagesLOW"An error occurred"
No rollback on failureHIGHPartial data on error

Validation Report Format

ALWAYS generate reports in this format:

markdown
## Code Validation Report

### Code Type: [type]
### Target: [DocType / App / File]
### Event/Trigger: [if applicable]

### CRITICAL ERRORS (Must Fix)
| # | Line | Issue | Fix |
|---|------|-------|-----|

### WARNINGS (Should Fix)
| # | Line | Issue | Recommendation |
|---|------|-------|----------------|

### SUGGESTIONS (Nice to Have)
| # | Line | Suggestion |
|---|------|------------|

### Corrected Code
[If critical errors found, provide corrected version]

### Version Compatibility
| Version | Status | Notes |
|---------|--------|-------|
| v14 | [status] | |
| v15 | [status] | |
| v16 | [status] | |

### Referenced Skills
- frappe-skill-name: [what was validated against]

Validation Depth Levels

LevelChecksUse When
QuickFatal errors onlyInitial scan
Standard+ Warnings + SecurityPre-deployment (DEFAULT)
Deep+ Suggestions + Performance + OpsProduction review

Skill Catalog Cross-Reference

This validator validates against ALL 61 frappe-* skills:

Syntax Validation (11 skills)

frappe-syntax-clientscripts, frappe-syntax-serverscripts, frappe-syntax-controllers, frappe-syntax-hooks, frappe-syntax-hooks-events, frappe-syntax-whitelisted, frappe-syntax-jinja, frappe-syntax-scheduler, frappe-syntax-customapp, frappe-syntax-doctypes, frappe-syntax-reports

Implementation Validation (12 skills)

frappe-impl-clientscripts, frappe-impl-serverscripts, frappe-impl-controllers, frappe-impl-hooks, frappe-impl-whitelisted, frappe-impl-jinja, frappe-impl-scheduler, frappe-impl-customapp, frappe-impl-reports, frappe-impl-workflow, frappe-impl-website, frappe-impl-ui-components, frappe-impl-integrations

Error Pattern Validation (7 skills)

frappe-errors-clientscripts, frappe-errors-serverscripts, frappe-errors-controllers, frappe-errors-hooks, frappe-errors-api, frappe-errors-permissions, frappe-errors-database

Core Pattern Validation (7 skills)

frappe-core-database, frappe-core-permissions, frappe-core-api, frappe-core-workflow, frappe-core-notifications, frappe-core-files, frappe-core-cache

Ops Validation (8 skills)

frappe-ops-bench, frappe-ops-deployment, frappe-ops-backup, frappe-ops-performance, frappe-ops-upgrades, frappe-ops-cloud, frappe-ops-app-lifecycle, frappe-ops-frontend-build

Testing Validation (2 skills)

frappe-testing-unit, frappe-testing-cicd

Quick Validation Commands

Server Script: 5-point check
  1. Any import statements? --> FATAL
  2. Any self. references? --> FATAL (use doc.)
  3. Any try/except? --> WARNING (usually wrong)
  4. Uses frappe.throw() for validation? --> GOOD
  5. Uses doc.field for access? --> GOOD
Client Script: 5-point check
  1. Any frappe.db.* calls? --> FATAL
  2. Any frappe.get_doc() calls? --> FATAL
  3. frappe.call() without callback? --> FATAL
  4. Uses frm.doc.field for access? --> GOOD
  5. Uses frm.refresh_field() after changes? --> GOOD
Controller: 5-point check
  1. Modifying self.* in on_update? --> FATAL
  2. Missing super().method() calls? --> ERROR
  3. self.save() in lifecycle hook? --> FATAL
  4. Imports at top of file? --> GOOD
  5. Error handling for external calls? --> GOOD
hooks.py: 5-point check
  1. Valid Python syntax? --> Check
  2. Function paths exist? --> Check
  3. v16-only hooks marked? --> Check
  4. required_apps complete? --> Check
  5. Fixture filters present? --> Check
Bench/Ops: 5-point check
  1. bench migrate after changes? --> REQUIRED
  2. Backup before destructive ops? --> REQUIRED
  3. Scheduler enabled? --> Check
  4. Workers running? --> Check
  5. SSL configured (production)? --> Check

See references/checklists.md for complete checklists. See references/examples.md for validation examples.

© Impertio-Studio, MIT. Rendered from Markdown: HTML in the file is shown as text, images as links, and headings moved down two levels. Raw file

Files

SKILL.md and 3 other files (references) in skills/source/agents/frappe-agent-validator of Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package.

  • SKILL.md
  • references/checklists.md
  • references/examples.md
  • references/workflow.md

Open the folder on GitHubat commit 36cfa80

Compare with similar skills

Frappe Agent Validator next to the 5 skills that share the most tags, products or categories with it. Stars are the repository's; “used in” counts other GitHub owners with a copy.

Frappe Agent Validator compared with similar skills
SkillStarsUsed inTokensAuto-checkLicenceRepo updated
Frappe Agent Validator this skillImpertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package187—~2.8kAutomated safety check: PassMIT
Code Review21pounder/terminalAgent1201 repos~650Automated safety check: PassApache-2.0
Code Review AssistantArabelaTso/Skills-4-SE253—~3kAutomated safety check: PassApache-2.0
WooCommerce Code Reviewwoocommerce/woocommerce11k3 repos~1.1kAutomated safety check: PassCustom licence
Skill Doli Code ReviewDolibarr/dolibarr7.7k1 repos~1.1kAutomated safety check: PassMIT
Dignified Python Standardsdocling-project/docling69k—~1.5kAutomated safety check: PassApache-2.0

Similar skills

  • Code Review

    21pounder/terminalAgent

    A skill your agent uses when user asks to "review code", "check for issues", "analyze code quality", "find bugs", or wants feedback on code implementation.

    120 GitHub starsUsed in 1 repo~650 tokens
    DevelopmentAuto-check passed
  • Code Review Assistant

    ArabelaTso/Skills-4-SE

    Conduct comprehensive code reviews identifying bugs, security issues, performance problems, code quality concerns, and best practice violations.

    253 GitHub stars~3k tokensUpdated 1 mo ago
    DevelopmentAuto-check passed
  • WooCommerce Code Review

    woocommerce/woocommerce

    Reviews WooCommerce code changes against the project's standards, flagging backend PHP architecture, naming, documentation, data integrity and testing violations.

    11k GitHub starsUsed in 3 repos~1.1k tokens
    DevelopmentAuto-check passed
  • Skill Doli Code Review

    Dolibarr/dolibarr

    Reviews Dolibarr PHP code for compliance with coding standards and security best practices, and fixes identified issues.

    7.7k GitHub starsUsed in 1 repo~1.1k tokens
    DevelopmentAuto-check passed
  • Dignified Python Standards

    docling-project/docling

    Applies opinionated production Python conventions chosen by the project's Python version: modern type syntax, pathlib, explicit checks and interface guidance.

    69k GitHub stars~1.5k tokensUpdated today
    DevelopmentAuto-check passed
  • Clean Code Guard

    amElnagdy/guard-skills

    Reviews generated or changed production code against Clean Code, SOLID, DRY, KISS, YAGNI and LLM-specific failure modes before it ships, in any language.

    1.3k GitHub starsUsed in 2 repos~4.3k tokens
    DevelopmentAuto-check passed

More from Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

All 61 skills in this repo
  • Frappe Agent Interpreter

    Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

    A skill your agent uses when receiving vague or unclear ERPNext/Frappe development requests that need interpretation.

    187 GitHub starsUsed in 1 repo~3.2k tokens
    Auto-check passed
  • Frappe Ops Website Deploy

    Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

    Deploy HTML/CSS websites to ERPNext/Frappe (v15/v16) as Web Pages via the REST API.

    187 GitHub stars~2.5k tokensUpdated 21 days ago
    Auto-check passed
  • Frappe Core API

    Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

    A skill your agent uses when building ERPNext/Frappe API integrations (v14/v15/v16) including REST API, RPC API, authentication, webhooks, and rate limiting.

    187 GitHub starsUsed in 1 repo~3.2k tokens
    Auto-check passed
  • Frappe Errors API

    Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

    A skill your agent uses when debugging or handling API errors in Frappe/ERPNext v14/v15/v16.

    187 GitHub starsUsed in 1 repo~4k tokens
    Auto-check passed
  • Frappe Impl Hooks

    Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

    A skill your agent uses when implementing hooks.py configurations in a Frappe custom app.

    187 GitHub starsUsed in 1 repo~3k tokens
    Auto-check passed
  • Frappe Impl Whitelisted

    Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package

    A skill your agent uses when building API endpoints with @frappe.whitelist() in Frappe.

    187 GitHub starsUsed in 1 repo~3.1k tokens
    Auto-check passed

Categories

Questions about Frappe Agent Validator

What does Frappe Agent Validator do?

A skill your agent uses when reviewing or validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls. Frappe Agent Validator is an agent skill from Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package. Use when reviewing or validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls.

When should I use Frappe Agent Validator?

Frappe Agent Validator fits situations like: validating Frappe/ERPNext code against best practices and common pitfalls; tasks that involve Code review; tasks that involve Debugging.

How do I install Frappe Agent Validator in Claude Code?

Run `npx skills add Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package --skill frappe-agent-validator -a claude-code`. Or copy the skill folder (skills/source/agents/frappe-agent-validator in Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package) into .claude/skills/frappe-agent-validator in your project. Claude Code loads it when a task matches its description.

How do I install Frappe Agent Validator in Codex?

Run `npx skills add Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package --skill frappe-agent-validator -a codex`. Or copy the skill folder (skills/source/agents/frappe-agent-validator in Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package) into .agents/skills/frappe-agent-validator in your project. Codex loads it when a task matches its description.

Can I use Frappe Agent Validator in Cursor, Gemini CLI or GitHub Copilot?

Cursor, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot and OpenCode also load SKILL.md folders. With the skills CLI, run `npx skills add Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package --skill frappe-agent-validator -a cursor` (or -a gemini-cli, github-copilot or opencode for the others). To copy it by hand, put the folder in .cursor/skills/frappe-agent-validator, .gemini/skills/frappe-agent-validator, .github/skills/frappe-agent-validator and .opencode/skills/frappe-agent-validator in your project.

What does Frappe Agent Validator need to run?

SKILL.md names no scripts, command-line tools or credentials: Frappe Agent Validator is instructions for the agent only. Our summary lists: Python 3. Compatibility (from SKILL.md): Claude Code, Claude.ai Projects, Claude API. Frappe v14-v16..

Does Frappe Agent Validator access the network?

SKILL.md contains no URLs. Any network use would come from the scripts or tools the agent runs. This is read from the text; nothing was executed.

Is Frappe Agent Validator safe to install?

Our automated static check of SKILL.md found no risky patterns, such as piping downloads into a shell, reading credential files or hidden Unicode. It is not a guarantee. Review the folder before installing.

What licence does Frappe Agent Validator use?

Frappe Agent Validator is published under the MIT licence (declared in SKILL.md). It allows redistribution, so the full SKILL.md is shown on this page.

How many tokens does Frappe Agent Validator use?

About 2.8k tokens (SKILL.md is roughly 11k characters). Agents keep only the skill's name and description in context until a task matches; then they load SKILL.md in full. Its references folder adds about 5.7k tokens, read only when the agent opens those files.

What are the alternatives to Frappe Agent Validator?

Skills that share tags, products or a category with Frappe Agent Validator: Code Review (21pounder/terminalAgent, 120 stars), Code Review Assistant (ArabelaTso/Skills-4-SE, 253 stars), WooCommerce Code Review (woocommerce/woocommerce, 11k stars) and Skill Doli Code Review (Dolibarr/dolibarr, 7.7k stars). The comparison table on this page puts their stars, adoption, token cost, safety result and licence side by side.

Who maintains Frappe Agent Validator?

Impertio-Studio (a GitHub organization) maintains it in Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package, which has 187 GitHub stars. The repository holds 61 skills in this directory. The repository was last updated on September 17, 2026.

Source: Impertio-Studio/Frappe_Claude_Skill_Package on GitHub. Facts on this page come from the repository at the commit we read; the author's words are quoted as theirs.