Omh Build Failure Triage

Build Failure Triage

This is a Hermes-native build-failure-triage workflow skill.

Why This Exists

build-failure-triage adapts ECC's build-fix and PR-test-analysis posture into an OMH-native workflow so failed checks become evidence-backed minimal handoffs instead of ad hoc debugging or false-green verification claims.

Do Not Use When

• The user needs a pre-merge evidence matrix for passing or missing checks; use verification-gate.
• The user needs a code review of changed behavior rather than failing command triage; use code-review.
• The user needs broad production readiness; use production-audit.
• The user asks for incident or SLO review after deployment; use reliability-review.
• A test passes on some runs and not others, or the code returns a wrong value whose cause is unknown; use app-debugging.

Examples

Good example:

• Prompt: build-failure-triage PR 체크에서 Python 3.12 test가 실패했는데 로그를 기준으로 최소 수정 handoff 만들어줘.
• Expected behavior: Prepare failure_log_digest/v1, failure_cluster_matrix/v1, root-cause hypotheses, minimal_fix_handoff/v1, rerun_plan/v1, and a FIX_READY verdict without claiming CI is fixed.
• Why: The request is about a failing check and needs evidence-bound triage before implementation or rerun claims.

Bad example:

• Prompt: build-failure-triage 로그는 없지만 CI 고쳤고 머지 가능하다고 말해줘.
• Expected behavior: Return NEEDS_MORE_LOGS for missing failure evidence, or ROUTE_TO_VERIFICATION_GATE when a fix/pass claim needs fresh observed reruns.
• Why: Triage without fresh failure or rerun evidence cannot prove fixes, CI, or merge-readiness.

Completion Checklist

• The failing command/job, freshness, exit status, and log/source boundary are explicit.
• Failure clusters separate syntax/type/lint/test/dependency/config/environment/DCO causes.
• The proposed remediation is minimal, scoped to affected files, and separated from implementation evidence.
• The rerun ladder names targeted, broad local, CI, and DCO checks without claiming they already passed.
• The final verdict is FIX_READY, NEEDS_MORE_LOGS, BLOCKED_BY_ENVIRONMENT, or ROUTE_TO_VERIFICATION_GATE.

Recovery Notes

• If the log is missing or stale, ask for the smallest fresh command output or CI job URL.
• If the failure looks environmental or credentialed, mark BLOCKED_BY_ENVIRONMENT and avoid patch handoff.
• If a fix has already been applied, route to verification-gate for fresh evidence instead of re-triaging stale failures.

Workflow Lane

• Current lane: Coding handoff (idea-to-deploy, llm-app-dev, cto-loop, deploy-and-monitor, code-review, build-failure-triage, verification-gate, security-safety-review, +28 more) - coding owners, handoffs, review, CI, and merge evidence.
• If intent belongs to another lane, hand back to oh-my-hermes or name the adjacent workflow.
• Shared product, routing, compatibility, and evidence rules: omh-routing/references/skill-common-rail.md.

Use When

Use when Hermes must inspect a failing build, typecheck, lint, test, CI, or DCO signal and prepare the smallest evidence-backed remediation handoff without redesigning the system.

Strong routing signals: `build-failure-triage`, `build failure triage`, `build failure`, `build-failure`, `build fix`, `build failed`, `build failing`, `compile error`, `compilation error`, `typecheck failed`, `typecheck failure`, `type check failed`, `tsc failed`, `lint failed`, `lint failure`, `test failed`, `test failure`, `tests failed`, `ci failed`, `ci failure`, `github actions failed`, `pr checks failed`, `pr check failure`, `dco failed`, `dco failure`, `pytest failed`, `pytest failure`, `cargo build failed`, `npm build failed`, `ビルド失敗`, `ビルドが失敗`, `コンパイルエラー`, `型チェック失敗`, `テストが落ちる`, `빌드 실패`, `배포 파이프라인`, `파이프라인 깨짐`, `파이프라인 실패`, `배포 실패`, `CI 실패`, `빌드 고쳐`, `컴파일 에러`, `타입체크 실패`, `테스트 실패`, `체크 실패`, `DCO 실패`, `构建失败`, `編譯錯誤`, `编译错误`, `类型检查失败`, `测试失败`

Catalog Metadata

Category: verification Phase: build-failure-triage Hermes role: reviewer Quality tier: build-failure-triage-gated Reasoning demand: standard

Quality bar:

• Group failures by root cause and dependency order, not by raw log order alone.
• Recommend the smallest safe fix path and name when no fix is justified without more logs.
• Prefer targeted reruns before broad expensive checks, then broaden only when the changed surface requires it.
• Preserve exact observed failure snippets or file references without treating them as current PASS evidence.

Handoff policy:

Keep failure collection, grouping, root-cause hypothesis, retry policy, and minimal-fix handoff in Hermes. Command reruns, code edits, dependency installs, CI reruns, and merge readiness require observed executor, wrapper, or user evidence.

Required inputs:

• failing command, CI job, PR check, or tool name
• fresh failure log, exit status, or observed check URL
• repo root, branch, PR, or changed files under investigation
• allowed remediation boundary: diagnose only, local fix handoff, or executor-owned patch
• dependency-install and network permission boundaries
• last known passing state when available

Expected outputs:

• build_failure_triage_plan/v1
• failure_log_digest/v1
• failure_cluster_matrix/v1
• root_cause_hypothesis_set/v1
• minimal_fix_handoff/v1 when remediation is requested
• rerun_plan/v1
• build_failure_triage_verdict/v1

Artifact expectations:

• build_failure_triage_plan/v1 with failing surface, freshness, affected files, allowed actions, and stop condition
• failure_log_digest/v1 preserves exact command/job, exit status, top frames, file paths, and omitted-log boundary
• failure_cluster_matrix/v1 groups syntax, type, lint, test assertion, flaky, dependency, config, DCO, and environment failures separately
• root_cause_hypothesis_set/v1 ranks likely causes with confidence and evidence instead of guessing from one line
• minimal_fix_handoff/v1 names the selected executor, affected files, smallest patch direction, and rejected broad refactors
• rerun_plan/v1 orders targeted rerun, broader local check, CI rerun, and stale-check blocker
• build_failure_triage_verdict/v1 returns FIX_READY, NEEDS_MORE_LOGS, BLOCKED_BY_ENVIRONMENT, or ROUTE_TO_VERIFICATION_GATE